A recent poll conducted by a popular YouTube nurse influencer shed light on the ongoing superiority debate between General Nursing and Midwifery (GNM) and Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN). An overwhelming 86% of the respondents favoured BSN, while only 14% considered GNM to be the better option. However, it is important to consider various aspects before making a definitive judgment. In this article, we aim to challenge the common perception and shed light on why GNM holds its ground as a valuable alternative to B.Sc Nursing:

 

1. Time is Money:

• GNM offers a shorter duration compared to BSN, allowing individuals to enter the workforce sooner.

• Private institutions often charge lower fees for GNM, making it a more affordable choice.

• GNM is often the best choice for individuals with certain conditions such as age, economic constraints, or a non-science background.

 

2. Experience Matters:

• Practical bedside experience is highly regarded in the nursing field, often outweighing academic qualifications.

• Employers value the practical skills and knowledge gained through hands-on experience, making GNM graduates with one year of experience preferable to freshly graduated BSN nurses.

 

3. Government Job Equality:

• In most government job postings, GNM nurses with one year of experience are considered equal to BSN and Post Basic nurses.

• This equal footing post 1 year, provides GNM graduates with the same employment prospects and opportunities for growth as their BSN counterparts.

 

4. Master's Advancement:

• BSN students have a one-year advantage in pursuing master's degrees. BSN graduates can directly pursue M.Sc after one year of teaching/clinical experience.

• GNM graduates can also become eligible for M.Sc programs, after pursuing Post Basic B.Sc for two years, followed by one year of clinical/teaching experience.

 

5. Global Prospects:

• Most European countries and the NHS of United Kingdom do not differentiate between GNM and B.Sc graduates, offering similar employment opportunities.

• Most Gulf countries, however, prefer BSN graduates over GNMs.

• The requirements for the US, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand may vary, and further research is recommended to understand their specific criteria.

 

In Conclusion:

It is essential to dispel the notion that BSN is inherently superior to GNM. While B.Sc Nursing may have its advantages in terms of pursuing higher education, nursing teaching and research career, jobs in the middle east and specific job positions, it is essential to consider the comprehensive benefits that GNM brings to the table. From a financial investment standpoint to experience-based preferences and government job opportunities, GNM stands tall alongside BSN.

As a nursing student pursuing a B.Sc degree myself, I present these arguments based on facts and analysis of the nursing profession. It is crucial to recognize the value of General Nursing & Midwifery and appreciate its role in producing skilled and competent nurses. Ultimately, the choice between GNM and B.Sc Nursing should be made based on individual circumstances, career aspirations, and personal preferences.

 

P.S. - This article solely emphasizes the practical aspects of the two courses and does not delve into the academic rigor, standards, and depth of knowledge they entail.

 

Anket Chowdhury describes himself as a Student Nurse & Blogger and is currently pursuing his BSc (Nursing) from Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences.